Translate this Page

Search :

Welcome to Clash of Steel!

Featured battle : Engen and Stockach

Part of The French Revolutionary and Napoleonic Wars

Date : 03 May 1800

The advance of the Army of the Rhine through southern Germany/Switzerland towards Austria was met by the Austrians in almost equal strength [8 to 7 in favour of the French]. The battle resulted in a significant defeat for the Austrians under Baron von Kray.

Featured image :

German WW1 Equipment - MUR3_IR28_g98

German WW1 Equipment - MUR3_IR28_g98

Pack and weapons of the German Infantry Regiment nr.28 of 1914

Gallery updated : 2018-09-21 16:58:22

Featured review :

Waterloo. Myth and Reality

Gareth Glover
It is an under statement to say there have been many books written about Waterloo. I have over ninety on my bookshelves; the earliest in my collection was printed in 1896 and there is a steady progression up to the present day. Why read another one? My first reason is that I am a Gareth Glover fan. The second reason, which is what drew me to this book, is the intriguing sub title ‘Myth and Reality’.
Glover sets out to separate the two by referencing hugh amounts of primary source material; much of which the reader can access for themselves in ‘The Waterloo Archives’ [Edited by Glover and reviewed on this site]
The author really does succeed in his aim to dispel most of the myths which appear in so many books. He presents cogent arguments in favour of ‘reality’ and for every case he has the supporting evidence. Where there is certainty it is stated with conviction, where there is doubt the balance of evidence is presented. The method employed is to give the appropriate weight to any piece of evidence by asking who wrote it, when and why. He goes on to show how some received wisdom is the result of the uncritical acceptance of records of events written by participants, or long after the event by their supporters, wishing to put down on record the version which shows them in the best light.
Glover also criticises those historians who base their judgements of commander’s decisions made in the heat of battle, when those decisions were based only on information available to them at that time. The fog of war and the difficulty of clear rapid communication do not cloud hindsight but did hamper all levels of command at that time.
It is not a large book, only 245 pages, but of well written engaging text. The sixteen pages of illustrations are superb. In such an excellent book it is a shame that my usual criticism of many modern books applies here. The maps are not good, without scale, without the conventional military mapping differences between cavalry and infantry, and a fancy type face which does nothing to aid the reader.
Maps apart I believe that for every person interested in the battle of Waterloo this book is more than a ‘would like’ it is a ‘must have’.

Pen & Sword Military. Pen & Sword \Books \Ltd., 2014

Reviewed : 2018-01-03 12:46:19